| 1920 |
Century Milstead |
All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1925 |
Clifford Parr |
All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1927 |
Perry Loer |
All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1934 |
Lloyd "Doc" Joyce |
All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1948 |
William Duchon |
Little All-America |
|
Joe Lovas |
Litle All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1949 |
Frank Roman |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1952 |
Stan Huntsman |
Little All-America |
| 1953 |
Stan Huntsman |
Little All-America |
| 1956 |
Gil Shoaf |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1959 |
Brian Bragg |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1961 |
Jon "Jack" McHenry |
Little All-America |
| 1963 |
Lynn Garrard |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1970 |
Roscoe "Lee" Fouts |
Academic Little All-America |
| 1971 |
Don Shelbourne |
Academic Little All-America |
| 1972 |
Joe Haklin |
Academic Little All-America |
| 1976 |
James "Jimmy" Parker |
Associated Press Little All-America First Team |
| 1977 |
Dave Harvey |
Kodak Little All-America |
| 1978 |
Bill Cannon |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1979 |
David Broecker |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Tim Kennedy |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Mick Martin |
Little All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1980 |
Mel Gore |
Division III All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Daryl Johnson |
Division III All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1981 |
Pete Metzelaars |
Division III All-America First Team |
|
Daryl Johnson |
Division III All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1983 |
David Broecker |
National Football Foundation Hall of Fame Graduate Fellowship |
| 1985 |
Bill Kaiser |
Football News All-America First Team |
| 1986 |
Carl Hampton |
National Strength Coaches Association All-America |
|
Jay Herrmann |
Football New All-America Second Team;
National Football Foundation Hall of Fame Graduate Fellowship |
| 1988 |
Mike Funk |
Football Gazette All-America Second Team |
|
Tim Pliske |
Kodak All-America First Team |
| 1989 |
Brett Butler |
Pizza Hut All-America Second Team |
|
Mike Funk |
Kodak All-America First Team;
Pizza Hut All-America First Team |
| 1990 |
Tim Oliver |
National Football Foundation Hall of Fame Postgraduate Scholarship |
| 1991 |
Jason Gallman |
Football Gazette All-America Second Team |
|
Brian Reising |
Champion All-America Third Team;
Football Gazette All-America Third Team |
|
Eric Schoettle |
Champion All-America Second Team |
| 1992 |
Eric Schoettle |
Champion All-America Third Team |
| 1993 |
Sean Lyons |
Football Gazette All-America Third Team;
Champion All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Chris Wiesehan |
Football Gazette All-America Third Team |
| 1994 |
Sean Lyon |
Champion All-America Third Team |
| 1996 |
Jake Gilbert |
Hewlett Packard All-America Honorable Mention |
| 1997 |
Chet Craft |
Football Gazette All-America Second Team;
Hewlett Packard All-America Third Team |
| 1998 |
Jamie Bowers |
Football Gazette All-America Third Team;
Hewlett Packard All-America Third Team |
|
Jim McHugh |
Hewlett Packard All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Matthew Rose |
Football Gazette All-America Second Team;
Hewlett Packard All-America Second Team |
| 2001 |
Jamie Bopp |
Hewlett Packard All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Ryan Short |
D3football.com All-America Second Team;
Football Gazette All-America Second Team;
Hewlett Packard All-America First Team |
| 2002 |
Nate Boulais |
Hewlett Packard All-America First Team |
|
Josh Bronaugh |
Football Gazette All-America Second Team |
|
Jake Knott |
Hewlett Packard All-America Third Team |
|
Ryan Short |
American Football Coaches Association All-America First Team;
Associated Press Little All-America Third Team;
D3football.com All-America First Team;
Hewlett Packard All-America First Team |
| 2003 |
Blair Hammer |
D3football.com All-America First Team |
| 2005 |
Russ Harbaugh |
D3football.com All-America Second Team;
Football Gazette All-America Honorable Mention;
Gagliardi Trophy Semifinalist |
|
Adrian Pynenberg |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
| 2006 |
Dustin Huff |
Football Gazette All-America Third Team |
|
Frank Knez |
Football Gazette All-America Second Team |
|
Adrian Pynenberg |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Mike Russell |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
| 2007 |
Adrian Pynenberg |
American Football Coaches Association All-America First Team;
Associated Press Little All-America Third Team;
D3football.com All-America First Team;
Gagliardi Trophy Semifinalist |
| 2008 |
Darryl Kennon |
D3football.com All-America Second Team |
|
Jared Lange |
American Football Coaches Association All-America First Team |
|
Tony Neymeiyer |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
| 2009 |
Wes Chamblee |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Addrian Frederick |
D3football.com All-America First Team |
|
Evan Isaacs |
American Football Coaches Association All-America Second Team |
| 2010 |
Weston Kitley |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Jonathan Koop |
D3football.com All-America First Team |
| 2011 |
Wes Chamblee |
D3football.com All-America First Team |
|
CJ Gum |
D3football.com All-America First Team |
| 2013 |
Cody Buresh |
D3football.com All-America First Team |
|
Nate Scola |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Cameron Sobleski |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
| 2014 |
Cody Buresh |
American Football Coaches Association All-America First Team;
D3football.com All-America Second Team |
| 2015 |
Tyler McCullen |
American Football Coaches Association All-America First Team;
D3football.com All-America Second Team |
|
Mason Zurek |
Associated Press Little All-America Third Team;
D3football.com All-America Second Team |
| 2016 |
Austin Brown |
D3football.com All-America Third Team |
| 2019 |
Joey Annee |
D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention |
| 2021 |
Joey Annee |
D3football.com All-America Second Team |
| 2022 |
Penn Stoller |
D3football.com All-America Second Team |
