Wabash College senior Mawuli Nevis, juniors James Day and Ayden Lutes, sophomore Titus Waters, and freshman Jayden Young were named 2025 National Wrestling Coaches Association  Scholar All-Americans. The 2024-2025 Wabash squad also earned the Scholar All-America Team designation from the NWCA for its work in the classroom.
 
Nevis is a biology major and placed third at 165 pounds at the NCAA DIII Region V Tournament to earn a berth at the national championship meet. Day is also a biology major and qualified for the NCAA DIII national tournament at 133 pounds after finishing third in regional competition. He earned a fourth-place finish at the championships. Lutes, a chemistry and Spanish double-major, finished eighth in the  157-pound weight class at the Region V Tournament. Young won 33 matches as a freshman at 174 pounds to qualify for NWCA Scholar All-America honors.
 
Wrestlers must either finish in the top-eight places at the NCAA DIII Regional Tournament or compete in at least 15 matches and finish with a winning percentage of 66 percent or higher and have either a grade point average of 3.2 or higher over the past two semesters or a cumulative GPA of 3.2 or higher.
 
The 2024-2025 Little Giant squad received Team Scholar All-America honors with a 3.525 grade point average. Wabash was one of 30 teams to achieve Team Scholar All-America accolades.